What’s the best SIBO diet for treating and getting rid of symptoms?

What to eat when you have SIBO 

If you’ve got SIBO you might be desperately searching for what to eat to help yourself feel better. In this post I want to share more about how different diets affect SIBO, and how to decide what to eat. 

Understanding SIBO

SIBO occurs when there is an excessive growth of bacteria in the small intestine. This can lead to various complications, including bloating, gas, abdominal pain, and altered bowel movements. 

There are two schools of thought when it comes to what to eat with SIBO. The challenge is a lack of research data to support either position. A review of treatments for SIBO in 2022 found ‘studies are still scarce and of low quality, limiting their clinical applicability’. 

From my experience working with hundreds of people who have IBS and SIBO, treating the SIBO cannot be done by diet alone. This is backed up by research showing antibiotics or antimicrobial treatments are effective at reducing SIBO. The evidence for SIBO diets is very patchy and the studies are low quality, on the whole.

Reducing your SIBO symptoms naturally

The reason people focus on diet, alongside treatment, is mainly to reduce symptoms. You want to get your bloating, diarrhoea and pain under control as quick as you can. 

Dietary approaches when you have SIBO

There are two schools of through on whether you should include fibre in the diet or not. Diet on it’s own will not get rid of the bacterial overgrowth. 

Starve the SIBO bacteria with diet

One suggestion is to starve out the overgrowing microbes by removing all the starches from your diet, and treat the overgrowth at the same time. 

You may find your symptoms reduce as you cut down on fibre. Unless you retest your SIBO levels, it’s not clear whether the digestive improvements are just from reducing down the substrates for the microbes, or an actual reduction in bacteria. 

Feed the SIBO bacteria with diet

The second method is to continue eating fibre and other carbohydrates alongside taking the treatment for SIBO. The benefit of this approach is that you are less likely to have any nutritional deficiencies.

Also there is a school of thought that the microbes are more likely to be killed as they are replicating, making the treatment more effective. 

SIBO diets – what are the options? 

There are lots of different styles of low carb, low fibre diets in the online SIBO space.

The purpose of a SIBO diet is to reduce your intake of fibres that can be fermented by the gut microbes. The diets hope to reduce SIBO and it’s associated symptoms.

You can do this by avoiding fermentable oligosaccharides, disaccharides, monosaccharides and polyols (FODMAPs), which are short-chain carbohydrates that are osmotically active and fermentable by small intestinal bacteria.

Some SIBO diets go further in their restrictive guidelines.

SIBO diet options

The most common SIBO diets include

1. Specific Carbohydrate Diet (SCD), 
2. Low FODMAP Diet (LFD) 
3. SIBO Specific Food Guide – by Dr Siebecker 
4. SIBO biphasic diet by Dr Jacobi 
5. Elemental Diet

Specific Carbohydrate Diet (SCD)

This diet was developed for children with ongoing symptoms in coeliac disease. There is a list of ‘legal’ and ‘illegal’ foods.

The only carbohydrates allowed are monosaccharides, which allows many fruits and vegetables. The SCD excludes disaccharides and most polysaccharides, so doesn’t allow any grains, lactose, starchy vegetables. It’s use in SIBO has not been proven. 

Low FODMAP diet

The Low FODMAP diet is the most common IBS dietary intervention. It was developed by the Monash University, and is well tested. The low FODMAP diet works in around 75% of cases to help reduce symptoms. In the low FODMAP diet you remove fermentable carbohydrates to reduce bloating, gas, diarrhoea and pain. 

It’s thought there is a big overlap between IBS and SIBO, and many of the symptoms are the same. 

SIBO Specific Food Guide – by Dr Siebecker 

Dr Siebecker, regarded by many as the OG of SIBO practitioners, always recommends starting with the less restrictive diets first, before trying her controlled diet. Dr Siebecker’s diet is more controlled than the low FODMAP diet. It’s based on her clinical experience working with SIBO patients. 

SIBO biphasic diet by Dr Jacobi 

Dr Nirala Jacobi took Dr Siebeker’s diet and created a timed and phased approach to eating with SIBO.

The SIBO bi-phasic diet includes more restriction for 2 weeks, then expanding the diet out after. 

Elemental Diet for SIBO

This is a special diet made up of shakes, and no food, to be followed for 2-3 weeks. Its more of a treatment intervention than a diet to be followed.

It should only be prescribed by a doctor. Part of the reason for that is your mental health also needs to be taken into account.

Not eating for 3 weeks is hard! There is some evidence it can reduce the overgrowth of microbes in SIBO. 

Non-diet natural ways to treat SIBO

Alongside any dietary changes to manage your symptoms and treatment for SIBO, you may also want to look at ways to support your overall health. This could include interventions such as:

• Probiotics: Incorporating probiotics into your daily routine can be a game-changer. These beneficial bacteria help restore balance in the gut microbiome, combating the overgrowth of harmful bacteria associated with SIBO.
• Supplements for the gut lining – including slippery elm, psyllium, NAC or liquorice. 
• Supporting nutritional deficiencies – some nutrients are more likely to be low in SIBO, including iron, B vitamins including B12, fat soluble vitamins A, D, E and K and zinc. 

Dietary Changes to consider when you have SIBO

Crafting a suitable diet is a big part of managing SIBO effectively. It can take multiple rounds of treatment to get rid of SIBO, and so you need to eat the broadest selection of foods you can during that time. 

A tailored dietary approach can make a substantial impact on your journey to recovery. 

Everyone with SIBO will have different triggers, so this is where working with a nutritionist trained and experienced in SIBO can really help.

I can help you with understanding what foods to avoid, and what to eat, to planning meals that support your gut health. 

In summary

My overall approach would be to focus on whole, natural foods, and consider your biggest triggers from high-FODMAP foods that may exacerbate SIBO symptoms.

Opting for low-fermentation foods can minimise the production of gas in the gut, providing relief from bloating and discomfort. BUT, you don’t want to be on a restrictive diet for years and years because it can lead to reduced good bacteria in the large intestine, reduced immunity, and nutritional deficiencies.

And if you can reduce down your symptoms then you’re more likely to stick with the treatment.

What to eat after SIBO treatment – your maintenance diet

Following SIBO treatment, you might be keen to start eating normally again and get back to your favourite foods. This might not always be a good idea because your digestion won’t necessarily be better after one round of treatment (Read – 8 reasons you don’t feel better after SIBO treatment)

As your gut undergoes healing and restoration, consider the following dietary adjustments:

1. Gradual Reintroduction of Foods: Slowly reintroduce high-fibre foods and complex carbohydrates into your diet post-treatment. Monitor your body’s response to different foods and gradually expand your diet to include a variety of nutrient-rich options.
2. Probiotic and Prebiotic Foods: Incorporate probiotic and prebiotic-rich foods to promote a healthy balance of gut bacteria. Yoghurt, kefir, sauerkraut, and fibre-rich fruits and vegetables can support the growth of beneficial bacteria in your large intestine. 
3. Long-Term Maintenance: Establish sustainable dietary habits that prioritise gut health and overall well-being. Strive for a balanced diet that includes a variety of whole foods, adequate hydration, and mindful eating practices. Long term restriction of foods can lead to nutritional deficiencies. 

By tailoring your diet to different phases of your healing journey, you can optimise SIBO treatment outcomes and support long-term gut health.

Do you need help with SIBO and figuring out what to do next? Whether you’ve already done a treatment round, or you’re new to SIBO, I can help.

Read about my 3 month Gut Reset here. Book a free call if you want to ask me about working with me.